We've been helping Australians for 100 years

On the road

Agreed vs market value

02 December, 2025
2 min

Wondering which option is right for you? We break down the difference to help you make an informed decision.

Share this story:

Whether you’re buying a new set of wheels, switching insurers or renewing your policy, you might be questioning the difference between agreed and market value and which option is right for you. Here, we break down key considerations to help you decide.

    What's the difference between agreed and market value?

    Depending on the car insurance policy you’re looking at, you may have the option of choosing between agreed value or market value. This value refers to the amount your car will be covered for, and how much reimbursement you would receive, in the event your car is written off or stolen and unable to be found (total loss).

    Agreed value

    With this option, you’re able to choose the amount your car is covered for within a specified range. This amount should reflect the amount of money you believe your car is worth. If the amount is agreed to by your insurer, that’s the amount you’d be paid out in the event of a total loss claim.

    Considerations for agreed value arrangements

    • Choice: you get to nominate the amount your car is insured for.
    • Stability: the amount your car is insured for is locked in for the policy period.
    • Clarity: you have increased certainty around the compensation you’d be entitled to if your car is written off or stolen.

    Tip: Our Comprehensive and Comprehensive Plus policies give you the option to choose between agreed or market value.

    Market value

    The market value also dictates the maximum amount you’d be entitled to in the event of a total loss payout; however, it’s based on what your car is worth on the open market at the time of your claim, rather than a figure you choose. The market value is determined by your insurer, and can be based on:

    • local market prices
    • your car’s age and condition
    • kilometres travelled
    • any modifications, accessories and extras.

    It’s important to note that market value is not the same as trade-in value or what it would cost to replace your existing car with a new one.

    Considerations for market value arrangements

    • Choice: the amount your car is insured for will be dictated by the market.
    • Stability: the amount your car is worth may fluctuate over the policy period.
    • Clarity: you will only know the payout amount once you make a claim.

    Don’t forget...

    Agreed and market value aren’t the only things to consider when choosing a car insurance policy. Be sure to always check the Product Disclosure Statement (PDS) for all the ins and outs of what’s included, conditions of cover, and any limits that may apply.

    Helping you find the right car cover

    From basic to comprehensive, find the level of insurance that’s right for you.

    All content on the NRMA Insurance Blog is intended to be general in nature and does not constitute and is not intended to be professional advice.

    Tags

    Guide Insurance Car

    Related articles

    • 17 October, 2025
      On the road | NRMA Insurance Blog

      Comprehensive versus Third Party Fire and Theft

      Read article
      Insurance Guide
    • 30 March, 2025
      On the road | NRMA Insurance Blog

      What’s the difference between Compulsory Third Party and Third Party Property Damage Insurance?

      Read article
      Insurance Guide
    • 10 April, 2025
      On the road | NRMA Insurance Blog

      How to choose the right car insurance

      Read article
      Insurance Car Guide